“I’m Not A Hero!” (What If? Spider-Man #1 Comic Review)

What If? Spider-Man #1

Writer: Gerry Conway

Penciller: Diego Orlotegui

Inker: Walden Wong

Colorist: Chris O’Halloran

Letterer: VC’s Travis Lanham

Cover Artist: Patch Zircher

Variant Cover Artist: John Tyler Christopher

What If? Spider-Man is written by Gerry Conway, with art from Diego Orlotegui, and explores the different possibilities of what could’ve happened in the world of Spider-Man.

Synopsis:

Bitten by a radioactive spider while he was still in high school, Flash Thompson gained the power to do whatever a spider could, and more. With this power, he donned a suit and mask, going by the name of Spider-Man. However, no one taught him that with great power came great responsibility, and as he continues to be aggressive and reckless in his crime fighting, it’s only a matter of time before Flash realizes what truly makes a hero.

Thoughts:

This book has a whole lot going for it, with some fantastic character moments, parallels, and homages, but also a whole lot going against it. To start off with what I liked, I thought the art was very well done, and everyone all around did a great job. While the colors were lacking a bit, the rest of it is still gorgeous, especially the cover. Flash Thompson (before he became a better person) as Spider-Man is such a unique, but risky concept, and the way it was done here was very realistic. For one, I definitely enjoyed that, as it got down into the bare consequences of his actions, some of which are surprisingly astronomical. I won’t spoil what they were, but the culmination of those mistakes was beautifully done, and a great homage to a certain famous early Spidey comic.

However, it’s unfortunately held back by a few things, which is a shame because this is such an ingenious concept. My main problem is that the Unseen / Nick Fury Sr. narrates through the entire book, rather than just the beginning and the end. Much of the important stuff, such as how Flash became the Spider-Man he was today, is glossed over as he narrated, telling a philosophical story about soldiers that had no context here, since this version of Flash was never a soldier. It came across as rushed and forced, and never gave the story enough time to sink its teeth into the readers.

This leads into the other issue I had, which is that this story would be much better suited for a mini-series, rather than just a one-off. With most What If? issues, it serves its purpose as a one-off, but this one to me just has so much potential in it that its a shame it got overshadowed by the Unseen’s narration and the What If? format. It’s not a stretch to say that shocking things happen in this issue, and they might’ve hit closer to home if we got to know these versions of these characters for a bit longer.

Overall, this issue was an enjoyable read, but also a bit of wasted potential. Gerry Conway’s writing is superb, but needed to take a step back and allow the story to flow naturally. I hope in the future that this concept can be adapted into a small mini-series, but I wouldn’t hold my breath on it. I can definitely recommend this issue for anyone who wants to see more of Flash Thompson, but they’re not gonna get the one they grew to love.

Share to

Alec Thorn

Alec Thorn

Hey guys! My name is Alec Thorn, I’m 19 years old, and I’m currently a full-time student in college. I’ve loved comics and superheroes ever since I was a toddler, with my favorite comic book character being the one and only Peter Parker / Spider-Man. I have a major passion for acting and singing as well, doing both for as long as I can remember. Hope you all enjoy reading!
Summary
A great concept with some great moments, but held back by the format it's put under.
Good
  • Art is very well done
  • Concept is brilliant and unique
  • Writing is very well-done, with great homages
Bad
  • The narrator distracts from the story
  • Too short, would've served better as a mini-series
7.8
Good
Story - 7.7
Characters - 6.1
Art - 8.7
Writing - 8.5
Written by
Hey guys! My name is Alec Thorn, I’m 19 years old, and I’m currently a full-time student in college. I’ve loved comics and superheroes ever since I was a toddler, with my favorite comic book character being the one and only Peter Parker / Spider-Man. I have a major passion for acting and singing as well, doing both for as long as I can remember. Hope you all enjoy reading!

Have your say!

0 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>